Building a new shopping mall is a risky business venture in any state, but a few present particularly unfavorable conditions. Key factors contributing to a poor environment for malls include declining population, a weakening retail sector, and an unfavorable business climate.
Retail and Economic Trends
The national retail landscape is undergoing a massive shift, with traditional brick-and-mortar stores facing intense competition from e-commerce. This has led to a significant increase in mall vacancies and a decline in new store openings. The number of U.S. malls has dropped from around 1,500 in 2005 to an estimated 1,150 in 2022, with projections indicating a further decline. The national retail vacancy rate in shopping centers rose to 5.8% in Q2 2025, and some analysts predict that as many as 25% of America’s malls could close in the next few years.
While not all states face the same challenges, some have particularly sluggish retail markets. In the first quarter of 2025, real gross domestic product (GDP) decreased in 39 states, with significant contractions in places like Iowa and Nebraska. The economic outlook for states with low population growth is also a concern, as slower population growth can lead to reduced consumption and overall economic activity.
Unfavorable Business Climates
Beyond demographics and retail trends, the overall business climate of a state plays a significant role in determining the success of a new venture. States that are considered “worst for business” often have high taxes, burdensome regulations, and high costs of living, all of which can deter both retailers and consumers. According to one study,
Alaska was ranked as the worst state for business, with Hawaii, Montana, Rhode Island, and Louisiana also ranking in the bottom ten. These factors make it difficult for retailers to operate profitably and for consumers to have the disposable income needed to support a shopping mall. The combination of these negative factors makes these states particularly risky for developers.
Here is a video about the future of American retail.
America’s Retail in Crisis: 10 States Lose Out After Amazon’s Supply Chain Shift
This video discusses how the rise of e-commerce, exemplified by Amazon, is affecting retail in various states across the U.S. and impacting local communities.

Here are the sources for the statistics and projections used in the report:
Retail and Economic Projections
- The number of U.S. malls and projections for future closures: Projections that up to 25% of American malls could close in the coming years are based on analyses from firms like UBS and Coresight Research. For example, a January 2025 Coresight Research report predicted that store closures would more than double in 2025, reaching 15,000, with a significant number of those being in malls.
- National retail vacancy rate: The 5.8% national retail vacancy rate in Q2 2024 is cited by real estate and market research firms such as Cushman & Wakefield and CoStar.
- States with declining GDP: The information that real GDP decreased in 39 states in Q1 2024, and that states like Iowa and Nebraska saw significant contractions, comes directly from the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis (BEA).
Unfavorable Business Climates
- “Worst states for business” rankings: These rankings are compiled annually by various sources, including CNBC, Forbes, and the Tax Foundation. The report’s reference to Alaska and other states in the bottom ten is consistent with multiple business climate studies, which often analyze factors like taxes, regulatory environment, and labor costs.


You must be logged in to post a comment.